• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

The 1894 Lodge, Neighborhood Bar & Grill: Exceptional Dining Experience in New Washington, IN

The 1894 Lodge, Neighborhood Bar & Grill, located at 409 E Main St in New Washington, IN, seamlessly blends Americana charm with exceptional dining. Esteemed for its chef-driven menu, the establishment features standout dishes like the expertly cooked NY strip steak and savory meatloaf, alongside unique appetizers such as Brussels sprouts and goat cheese fritters. Guests rave about the top-notch service provided by a dedicated team, with personal touches that enhance the dining experience. With its inviting atmosphere and distinctive cocktails, The 1894 Lodge isn’t just a restaurant—it’s a culinary destination worthy of the journey.

The 1894 Lodge, Neighborhood Bar & Grill at a glance

  • Address 409 E Main St, New Washington, IN 47162, United States
  • Phone +1 812-628-9006
  • Restaurant type American restaurant , Catering food and drink supplier , Restaurant , Steak house .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

The 1894 Lodge, Neighborhood Bar & Grill: Reviews & Ratings

Chris K
5

Excellent food and service with hard-working staff. The hostess Amber was excellent and offered her help with cleaning and removing dishes from the table. Our waitress Carrie was also excellent and provided her opinion when we asked. We will definitely be back to see what other specials you may have. Hat off to the chef!!! The best food we've had in a year since Siesta Keys. Well done!!! We also enjoyed our conversation with Grandpa. It's worth the hour drive!!!!!

Chris Shipaila
5

If you are looking for an experience then this is your place. From the moment you enter to building until you leave you are taken care of by this amazing team. Why is this different than other spots? The food is all chef driven from the cocktails all the way to their yummy desserts!! Oh and don't let me forget about the amazing leadership who you can see bussing tables, cooking, pouring drinks....LOGAN!! I cannot say enough good things about the lodge and look forward to my next visit!

Mike LaMontagne
5

My wife and I went here for dinner a few weeks ago. Walking in the door definitely gives that great early Americana vibe. We had a Brussels sprouts appetizer, that was perfect! I had a NY strip steak, that was perfectly cooked and delicious! My wife had the meatloaf that she raved about! We will certainly go back! Great place, don’t miss out!

Michele Ryback
5

My husband and I visited during our road trip celebrating our first anniversary. The food was fantastic, and so was our server, Skyla.

Amy Hardy
5

First time dining here, but won't be the last! We made a reservation and mentioned it was for our anniversary. There was a card on our table when we sat down, very nice touch. Service was great, all the food and drinks were top notch. My meal of Chicken Marsala was amazing, some places make the sauce too sweet, but this was perfect and delicious. Also tried the goat cheese fritters, truffle fries, bread pudding and an Indiana sunset drink, all was fantastic. Other entrees sampled by our party was the NY strip, meatloaf and fish & chips everyone gave the food It was worth the drive and the atmosphere was very cool in an old school house!

Devan Gunderson Lindemier
5

Every time we have been here, the food is over the top excellent! The service is also personal and makes you feel like a neighbor and treasured guest. We have referred many here, even from out of the country! As I'm writing this, I'm realizing we need to go back...so maybe that's tonight! This is a true gem that everyone needs to visit. The chef is well trained, the servers are great, the atmosphere is unique and special, the cocktails are superb. They are doing it right!!

Kirsten Weinsheimer
5

Amazing food and staff! Worth the pretty drive, especially for a special date night. We went for our anniversary and they went above and beyond. My husband talked for a week straight about his Cajun pasta! Goat cheese fritters, cocktail, hot brown, Cajun pasta, and cheesecake were all too-notch! We can’t wait to go back

Sam
5

Off the beaten path in New Washington Indiana. This is an old 2 story church house that's been converted to a fine dining establishment. It's well worth the drive and the Chicken Marsala and Grilled Pork Chop are amazing. This is a very nice restaurant!

Location

  • The 1894 Lodge, Neighborhood Bar & Grill
    The 1894 Lodge, Neighborhood Bar & Grill
    409 E Main St, New Washington, IN 47162, United States Hotline: +1 812-628-9006

Welcome to The 1894 Lodge, Neighborhood Bar & Grill, a delightful spot nestled at 409 E Main St, New Washington, IN, that promises not just a meal, but an experience. As soon as you step inside, the early Americana vibe greets you—a charming aesthetic laden with history and warm ambiance. This isn’t just another eatery; it’s a place where fond memories are made and palate-pleasing dishes reign supreme.

What sets The 1894 Lodge apart is its commitment to chef-driven culinary art, which shines through in every offering. The menu is rich with carefully crafted dishes, each prepared with intention and passion. Guests rave about the hearty NY strip steak—cooked to perfection and bursting with flavor—and the beloved meatloaf, which has left many patrons singing its praises. As one customer fondly remarked, it was “the best food we've had in a year,” a testament to the kitchen’s capacity to impress even the most discerning of diners.

The reviews speak for themselves, with comments applauding the stellar service that complements the scrumptious offerings. From the moment you walk in, you’re met with a dedicated team. Customers have highlighted the attentiveness of staff members like Amber and Carrie, who go above and beyond, making your dining experience feel personal and inviting. And it’s evident that the leadership—personified by the multi-talented Logan who juggles various roles in the restaurant—fosters an atmosphere of warmth and camaraderie.

Diving into the appetizers, you cannot miss the Brussels sprouts, celebrated for their perfect seasoning and crispy texture. This comforting yet upscale starter sets the tone for what’s to come. And let’s not overlook the desserts—rumored to cap off your meal with sheer perfection, they are not to be missed. Mentioning the bread pudding that leaves patrons raving is essential; its flavor profile proves that attention to dessert can elevate a meal from great to unforgettable.

Couple this culinary journey with a selection of expertly curated cocktails, and you have all the makings of an evening well spent. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion, as many couples have, or simply looking to feast on a Friday night, The 1894 Lodge provides a destination that is worth every mile of travel.

So, gather your friends, bring your family, or enjoy a romantic dinner. With its inviting environment, exceptional service, and outstanding food, The 1894 Lodge, Neighborhood Bar & Grill ensures that each visit leaves you anticipating the next, making every drive to this charming lodge worth the while.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards